This
post at apartmenttherapy.com got me thinking about how I decide whether or not to do it myself or hire a pro. DH and I have a house that according to my mother "takes fixer upper to a whole new level," so we've done a lot of projects big and small. We've hired out, and done them ourselves.
One of the questions addressed in the post is time vs. money. Yeah, you probably (though not always) will save money, but your time is worth something too. The article suggests estimating your time needed and doubling it. I would say this is a vast understatement! Double what you think it will cost and perhaps triple or quadruple how long you think it will take.
In addition to time and money, it's important to consider the hassle of your job. This works both ways - I've hired people to avoid a hassle on some jobs, and done it myself to avoid a hassle on other jobs. What kinds of hassles? For DIY jobs, here's a few examples: Our local Home Depot is jam packed on weekends. Plan on several hours, fighting for a parking space, tackling someone to get help and waiting in line for 20 minutes. Anyone whose ever done a job knows it's almost always at least two trips to the hardware store. Professionals make their living doing measurements and calculations. Measuring accurately and getting perfect right angles is not easy, and an accumulation of small errors can mean a problem at the end. I've had to go to multiple stores to get supplies. It's often difficult to sort through conflicting advice.
When hiring out a job, there can be hassles too. In our area, contractors are so busy that many simply don't need your business and they act like it. They don't call back, don't show for appointments, come to look at the job an never provide a bid, etc. So it's a huge amount of time and effort to get the recommended 3 bids. Even if you hire a good contractor, my experience is that you still need a really high level of oversight to get the job done right. I am a stickler for my contractors putting every detail in writing, and even when something has been communicated verbally and in writing you still need to be present to make sure it gets done.
Another point covered in the article is your tolerance for less-than-perfect work. This is really important because your work will not be as good as a professional's in most cases. We made our own concrete countertop in our kitchen. I really wanted concrete, but it more than I was willing to spend (about $10,000!). We ended up doing it ourselves for a total cost of less than $1,000, which included a $300 tool. Our countertops are beautiful, and I have really enjoyed the bragging rights, especially when a contractor or city inspector is impressed. But, looking closely, you can see that they are not perfectly level and that many places the surface looks different due to needing different levels of grinding. I'm fine with this - I love that it looks hand made and not machine perfect and unless I point out the imperfections most people would never spot them. I have a friend though, who doesn't like anything imperfect or with marks from being hand made. She would rather have something different that looks perfect.
There are other times though, when I've done it myself because I felt that nobody would do the job as well as I wanted. I am finishing the interior wood surface of windows with shellac. I've invested several hundred hours, and am not even half done. Each surface needs to be sanded, cleaned, coated with shellac, allowed to dry, and then sanded, cleaned, coated, dried, etc for 3 coats. At the end, it gets buffed with old denim. It is detailed and time consuming, and even if I could find someone to do the job to my standards, what would it cost?
It's not an easy decision, whether to hire or DIY, but it is worth taking the time to make the right choice.
Bookmark this on Delicious